Chopped Off Witch Fingers Recipe (paleo,vegan) for Halloween

Halloween is coming up FAST!! I’m talking real fast. My Halloween plans are all over the place, there are so many nice parties and events I could go to and I’m just not finished deciding yet.. but what is for sure: I am making treats, candy, cake…just FOOD for Halloween.

I’m making guilt-free, super healthy food that looks either so scary you are afraid to eat it (you do you, the rest stays for me then;-)) or are dying to get your sweet tooth satisfied with ’em.

If you haven’t checked out my Fruit Monsters Recipe, click here!

So I decided to dedicate the last days before Halloween to making wonderful snacks, easy, healthy and ones that are sure to make an impression. That means I am doing my best to post everyday until Halloween. So be sure to leave me comments for the posts you’d like me to do and let’s get excited for Halloween with these

Chopped Off Witch Fingers


They are paleo cookies that can be veganized. I got the original recipe off Pinterest, but put my own spin to them. There were actually people I offered these to who refused to eat them, as they thought they looked to real!!
And the recipe and the simplicity literally blew my mind!

So if you want to scare somebody you’d better get to making these! Enjoy!


What you’ll need

For the fingers
  • 1/2 cup flour
  • 1/4 cup coconut oil
  • 1 1/2 tbsp honey or agave
  • pinch of salt
  • vanilla extract
  • almonds
For the blood
  • berries
  • honey or agave


Make sure the coconut oil is soft, not too fluid and stir the honey or agave (if you choose to go vegan) with the oil. Add the flour, salt and vanilla extract and mix thoroughly. Make sure you have a mould-able dough. Place the dough in the freezer for about 5 min or in the fridge for 20min while you prepare the “blood”.


For this simply heat up the berries and the honey or agave in the pot stirring constantly. You can blend everything if you want to or just leave it as it is.
Transfer the “blood” into a bowl or onto a plate.


Take out the dough for the fingers and with little parts mould finger shapes. Add almonds for the fingernails (makes them super creepy;-)) and press into the dough to create the little lines in the knuckles. I used a fork for this.


Place the finished fingers onto a baking sheet and bake them for about 20 to 25 minutes at medium high heat in the oven or until they darken.

You don’t have to add the spiders…;-) but ya can!

Take them out and let them cool fully. Then dip them or elegantly drown the fingers in blood;-) and enjoy the faces of the people you show them to!

I played around with some cauldron effects… just for fun!

Happy scaring and eating!! 



Plus, let´s be internet friends!
Follow me on Bloglovin´: @1617sunshineave
Follow me on Instagram: @littlesunshine01
Find me on Pinterest: @1617sunshineave


Posted by

Hey there beautiful people of the internet! I am a young student studying Biochemistry in Germany and blogging as I travel the world in my free time. I have a passion for all things travel, fitness, books and getting to know the lives of people from all over the world. I blog mostly about my travels, honestly and openly sharing my experiences. Sometimes I sprinkle a little bit of Fitness content in there as well, as I am also a certified personal trainer. So come join me in the ride that is this weird and crazy thing called life. I'm happy to have you here :) XO Little Sunshine

5 thoughts on “Chopped Off Witch Fingers Recipe (paleo,vegan) for Halloween

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s